Christian Porter, defamation barrister ordered to pay Jo Dyer’s legal costs Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content

Source
By Sarah McPhee

Christian Porter and his defamation barrister have been ordered to pay legal costs, expected to be in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, after losing a court fight with a friend of the woman who accused the federal minister Mr Porter of rape.

Jo Dyer launched Federal Court proceedings against prominent defamation barrister Sue Chrysanthou, SC, in May to stop her acting for Mr Porter in his defamation case against the ABC.

Christian Porter has been ordered to pay Jo Dyer’s legal costs.

Christian Porter has been ordered to pay Jo Dyer’s legal costs. Credit:Alex Ellinghausen

Ms Dyer had sought the court order on the basis that Ms Chrysanthou had previously advised her in relation to an article in The Australian that was published after she appeared in an ABC Four Corners broadcast in November last year about Mr Porter and others.

The parties disagreed about whether confidential information was imparted at a November 20 meeting between Ms Chrysanthou and Ms Dyer, which was also attended by senior Macquarie banker James Hooke, a former boyfriend of the woman who accused Mr Porter of raping her in the late 1980s when they were both teenagers. Mr Porter strenuously denies the rape allegation. The woman took her own life last year.

In an urgent decision on May 27, Justice Tom Thawley ruled that Ms Chrysanthou could not act for Mr Porter because of the risk of misuse of confidential information.

Defamation barrister Sue Chrysanthou, SC.

Defamation barrister Sue Chrysanthou, SC. Credit: Kate Geraghty

Mr Porter discontinued his high-stakes defamation claim against the ABC on May 31.

On Friday, the judge ordered the former attorney-general and prominent silk pay Ms Dyer’s legal costs.

Ms Chrysanthou had contended she should not be ordered to pay costs as she took a “neutral position” as an officer of the court when proceedings commenced and took no active part in the conduct of the proceeding.

Justice Thawley said that during cross-examination Ms Chrysanthou “accepted that she had assisted Mr Porter in these proceedings”.

“In the circumstances of this case, my view is that Ms Chrysanthou should not be relieved of an order that she pay the costs of the successful party,” the judge said.

Michael Bradley, managing partner of Sydney firm Marque Lawyers, representing Ms Dyer, said the costs outcome was “unsurprising since Jo’s victory was complete”.

“We are obviously pleased that the judge decided to make the costs order as well,” he said.

The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up here.

Ange Postecoglou Celtic move: Inside the Parkhead goldfish bowl Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
Madeline Groves raises serious issues but must add detail to her accusations Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
State of Origin 2021: NSW braced for $10 million boost after Blues’ thumping win Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
Donations pour in to Archives as historians decry decay of ‘national memory bank’ Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
Operation Ironside: Airport worker arrested and charged with drug trafficking and money laundering Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
‘Real generational change’: Chris Minns reveals new Labor frontbench Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
Race-by-race preview and tips for Randwick on Saturday Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
AFL 2021 LIVE updates: Sydney Swans v Hawthorn Hawks; round 13 fixtures, results, tipping, tickets, draw, odds, tickets
Olympic Games 2021: Australian surfers ready to ‘pack a sting’ in Tokyo Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content Loading 3rd party ad content
Geoffrey Edelsten found dead in Melbourne apartment